Castle Arts Gold vs Soft Touch – Which is Better? [Free Swatch Charts]

If you’ve been following along with our Castle Arts journey, you know we’ve been having so much fun testing these pencils — and today we’re taking it one step further! After swatching the Castle Arts Gold pencils last week, Steve and I just couldn’t stop there, so we went ahead and grabbed a full set of the original Soft Touch pencils to put them head-to-head. We wanted to answer the big question: if you could only buy one, which set would we actually recommend? On top of that, we spent days creating custom swatch charts in our own favorite color order for both the Gold and Soft Touch 120 sets, and we’re sharing those with you for free! Oh, and did we mention there’s a giant Castle Arts giveaway happening? Trust me, you’re going to want to stick around for that!

Video Description

After unboxing the Castle Arts Gold colored pencils last week, and after swatching the Gold, Pasteltint and Metallic pencils, Steve and I decided that our Castle Arts Journey would not be complete without testing the original Castle Arts Soft Touch colored pencils as well. So we went all in! Not only did we purchase a set of the Soft Touch pencils for ourselves, we also decided to purchase a second set to add to our already big Castle Arts Giveaway!

Watch me test the Castle Art Gold pencils against the Castle Art Soft Touch to see which one I would recommend (if you could only buy just one.)

While creating free Castle Arts swatch charts for you, we also decided to put the Gold and Soft Touch 120 sets into our very own color order. The order that the company recommends is decent, but we felt that it didn’t quite meet our needs. So we spent days swatching, comparing and re-swatching to get the Castle Arts 120 Pencil Sets into our favorite color order! See below for links to download these swatch charts.

Enter our Giant Castle Arts Colored Pencil giveaway where one lucky person will win a Full 120 Set of the Castle Art Gold Pencils, plus a case and other goodies; a 120 Set of Soft Touch pencils; a 48 set of the Pasteltint Pencils; a 48 set of the Metallic Pencils; and a copy of our Castle Arts Pencils Tri-Tone Workbook printed on our favorite colored pencil paper! Follow the link below to enter.

GIANT CASTLE ARTS PENCIL GIVEAWAY!
https://www.coloringbliss.com/win-a-big-set-of-castle-arts-colored-pencils/

RECOMMENDED COLORING BLISS PRODUCTS:

Coloring Bliss Swatch Books…
https://www.coloringbliss.com/shop-swatch-books/

AFFILIATE LINKS TO PRODUCTS SHOWN IN VIDEO:

Castle Arts Gold Colored Pencils – https://amzn.to/3zvZiRr

Castle Art Soft Touch Colored Pencils – https://amzn.to/3GomGTv

Castle Arts Pasteltint Pencils – https://amzn.to/3t2z342

Castle Art Metallic Pencils – https://amzn.to/3zsuhha

—
Coloring Bliss is NOT a sponsored channel/page unless indicated in the video/post. Occasionally some products are gifted by the manufacturer for review purposes, always with the understanding that Coloring Bliss is under no obligation to give anything but an honest review. These products are always disclosed. Some links provided are affiliate links which does not effect the price to the consumer but does give a small commission to help support this channel/page. Any questions or business inquiries, please contact support@coloringbliss.com
—
Website: https://www.coloringbliss.com
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/coloringpagesbliss/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ColoringBliss/
Facebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/ColoringPagesBliss/
Pinterest: https://www.pinterest.com/coloringbliss/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/coloringbliss
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/coloringpagesbliss

Transcript

Castle Arts Gold Series vs. Soft Touch Series: Full Set Head-to-Head Battle

Hello, everyone! My name is Jennifer Stay, and this is Coloring Bliss. Today I have a head-to-head colored pencil battle for you. We’re putting Castle Arts against Castle Arts — that’s right, the brand new Gold Series right here, and the Soft Touch Series, which I recently brought into my art studio so we could do this full set comparison between these two Castle Arts products.


A Massive Giveaway!

Before we get started, I have to tell you about the massive giveaway we’re doing. Giveaways are awesome, and they’re even more awesome when they’re bigger — right, Steve?

We started a giveaway last week, and with Steve’s help I’ve decided to make it even bigger. Here’s what one lucky winner will receive:

  • 48 Castle Arts Metallic Pencils
  • 48 Castle Arts Premium Pastel Tint Pencils
  • The gorgeous Gold 120 full set of Castle Arts pencils (in the case)
  • The Castle Arts 120 Soft Touch Pencils

Talk about full set syndrome satisfied! Everything you could ever want in the Castle Arts colored pencil world is coming your way.

There are a lot of ways to enter, so follow the link in the video description — but do it right away, because this giveaway ends January 26th. We’ll announce the winner on January 27th.

And Steve, there’s one more thing that goes with this giveaway. We don’t have it made yet, but the winner will also receive the Tritone Worksheets to help organize the vast majority of these pencils. So cool! That’s a total value of $227. Get your entries in, and good luck, everyone!


Free Swatch Charts

Now that you know about the giveaway, let’s talk about what we have for all of you — some free swatch charts and a whole lot of comparing, so you can learn a little more about the Gold Series and the Soft Touch Series.

We’ve been working so hard over the last few weeks, so let me show you all of the swatch charts that Steve — awesome guy that he is — has been creating for you.

These swatch charts are arranged in the preferred Coloring Bliss order. When we first got all these pencils, we swatched them in the order they came in the tin, or in the order the company suggested with their own swatch chart. We learned very quickly that it’s not a very helpful order — at least not for the way I like to color as an artist, and not for organizing by the color wheel.

So Steve and I spent days — literally days — pouring over these pencils, swatching, re-swatching, and a lot of times re-re-swatching all of them to get them into a beautiful order based on the artist’s color wheel. That way, it’s really easy for you to find colors and navigate through both sets. It’s been a lot of fun, but also a lot of work, and these free swatch charts are the end result.

Here’s what we created:

  • A large overview swatch chart for the Soft Touch Pencils (all 120), in our preferred order
  • A large overview swatch chart for the Gold Pencils (all 120), in our preferred order
  • A swatch chart for the Castle Arts Pastel Tints, kept in the pencil number order
  • A swatch chart for the Castle Arts Metallic Pencils, in the company’s suggested order (which, looking at it, is actually a pretty decent order)

We also created — well, Steve created — another version for both the Soft Touch and Gold sets that spreads the colors out across four pages per download. That gives you a larger swatch square where you can really color from heavy to light pressure and see the full range of each color. And again, these are all in our preferred order.

I am so excited to offer this to you, because it has been a massive amount of work to get it to a place that looks beautiful and makes a lot of sense.


Why Reorder? A Side-by-Side Look

So why go to all this trouble? Why not just swatch them in the order the company gave us?

Here is the Soft Touch set swatched in their recommended order — the way the pencils were laid out in the tin. And here is our preferred Coloring Bliss order, based on the color wheel, after hours and hours of work.

Let me get my face off the screen so you can really see why we go to all this trouble.

If you take the color wheel and lay it down next to their suggested order, you can see that we start moving into yellow-orange, then into orange, then into red-orange — and then suddenly we jump to red, then back to red-orange, and then one color has a lot of violet in it that I would have placed somewhere completely different. Then we’re back into reds, into red-violets. You can kind of see what I mean. It’s inconsistent, and a few colors are just in the wrong place altogether. That would make it really hard to find a good light, medium, and dark when you’re trying to create a beautiful, logical blend.

Now let’s look at our chart.

We start with yellows, and it naturally flows into yellow-oranges, then into beautiful oranges and red-oranges. There’s one really interesting dark brown in this section, but we worked hard at incorporating the browns into the correct areas of the color wheel. So if you need a really good dark, reddish-orange color for shadows, you know exactly where to reach. Moving along into the reds, you can see there are some interesting spots where unexpected colors appear — but they make total sense. It’s usually the browns, those really complex tertiary colors, or colors where they’ve added a lot of gray. That grayish-pink, for example — where does it belong? Now you know.


Unboxing the Soft Touch Set

I want to roll some unboxing footage, because last week I showed you the Gold Series and the other two tins, but I thought you’d like to see what’s included in the Soft Touch full box — the tin, the inserts, and everything that comes with it.

For the Soft Touch, we decided to get the tin instead of the canvas bag we chose for the Gold, simply because I wanted to see what the full set tin experience was like. You can see it includes a few inserts and comes with three trays with nice elastic bands to make it easy to lift the trays in and out. These trays fit really nicely inside the tin — unlike the Pastel Tints and the Metallics tins, which I was really struggling with. This tin and these trays are a great match.


Analyzing the Sets as a Whole

One of the great things about this sorting project is that it gave us a really unique opportunity to look at each set as a whole. How well does it stand on its own? Are there enough blues? Enough reds? Enough light tones? Enough deep, dark tones?

The first thing we did was take all the pencils out and put them into my new organizer according to the color wheel. I have 12 slots — one for every color on the color wheel — and we placed all the pencils into rough positions based on where they seemed to belong. This was fantastic because at a glance, I could see how many pencils landed in each section of the color wheel, and it revealed some pretty glaring imbalances in how many pencils were assigned to each color category.

After the sorter step, it was time to actually swatch everything and refine where each pencil truly belonged. And saying it like that makes it sound simple — but it wasn’t. We made sure to do this entire process under good studio lights, and we had to make judgment calls: does that brown lean more orange, or does it lean more red? Does it even lean violet? Some of the browns actually leaned violet. I leaned on Steve heavily throughout this process — he has such a great eye for color. We used the color wheel and literally laid swatches along it to refine the placement of each one.

That was just the second step. The third step was laying everything out once we had them mostly in the right place, and then deciding: does this color lean cool or warm? Does it go before or after this one? Some were really tricky because of heavy gray or black mixed in. Others were straightforward — this one is clearly yellow-green, and this one is clearly green. Easy.

Let me show you the work we went through to get here. Look at all these arrows — this was literally hours and days of work. “Don’t put it here, put it there.” “No, move it this way.” “Actually, go that way.” It looks like a madman’s maze. And even then we were still making changes.

That was just the work for the Gold Series. There’s an equal stack of notes for the Soft Touch. It was amazingly difficult, but once it’s done, you’re left with this really harmonious layout of colors where you can quickly make meaningful comparisons between the two sets.


Color Balance: Gold vs. Soft Touch

Let me get the swatch charts on screen so we can look at them together. Steve, I don’t think you’ve seen these laid out side by side like this yet, so let’s look at them together.

When I started this project, I was leaning toward the Gold pencils as my favorite set. But what we discovered is that the Soft Touch pencils are actually a slightly better-balanced set when it comes to color distribution.

Here’s what I mean:

Yellows and warm colors: Starting from yellow and moving toward the warmer colors, you can see the Gold set moves into yellow-oranges right away, while the Soft Touch gives you a little more room in that warm yellow zone.

Reds: The Gold set is super heavy with reds — tons and tons of red colors. The Soft Touch felt a little more balanced, moving into red-violets a bit sooner and offering better red-oranges overall.

Blues: This is where things get really telling. In the Gold set, you can see we go from blue-violet land right into blue, and then almost immediately into blue-green. There are maybe four or five basic blues total, and there’s no really good light blue. The closest thing to a light blue in the Gold set actually leans pretty green. The Soft Touch does a little better here — there are a few more options in the blue zone. Still heavy on the reds, but better balanced.

Greens: The same story continues. Push through the blue-greens and into the greens, and the Soft Touch has noticeably more. If you color landscapes, flowers, or anything nature-related, a wide variety of greens is really important. The Gold set isn’t terrible in this area, but the Soft Touch clearly wins.

Grays: Interestingly, it’s the opposite situation here. The Gold set gives you more grays — warm grays, cool grays, and then one black and one white. I wish it had a nice light cool gray, but it doesn’t. The Soft Touch gives you a ton of grays, which honestly I love. But if I’d had the chance to sit down with the designers, I would have said: “Let’s pull back on the grays and add more blues and greens.”

And I think what happens a lot with more affordable pencils — many of which are manufactured in China — is that they tend to come from a limited number of factories, so you end up with colors that are nearly duplicates of each other. Why not drop one of those near-duplicate pinks and bring in another blue? Some of those gray-blues are so similar that if you blink, you’d swear they were the same pencil. You end up with no real light blues and no strong dark blues either. As a colorist, it’s really important to have good contrast from light to dark so you can create those beautiful, seamless blends.


The Case for Adding Pastel Tints

That’s exactly why, after doing this exercise and seeing the colors grouped together, I started to reconsider whether I should be steering everyone toward the Soft Touch rather than the Gold.

Here’s the thing: if you add the Pastel Tints alongside the Soft Touch line — and technically they are the same line of pencils — suddenly you have a light blue, even more light yellows, and a nice cool light gray. It fills out and completes the set beautifully.

So my first recommendation is this: if you invest in the Soft Touch pencils, adding the Pastel Tints will make you so much happier with the color selection and your ability to create beautiful blends. It’s really a must.

In fact, we originally considered doing our Tritone worksheets with the Gold set, but there simply isn’t enough tonal variation to build good tritones for every color on the color wheel with the Gold set alone. With the Pastel Tints paired with the Soft Touch, though, we feel confident. So the Tritone project will be built around the Soft Touch line.

The bottom line: the Soft Touch set — especially paired with the Pastel Tints — is a better-balanced, more complete set for creating strong tonal contrast than the Gold set. But that’s just one factor. There’s more to talk about.


Can You Combine the Pastel Tints with the Gold Set?

Quick answer: yes. Technically, the Pastel Tints are part of the Soft Touch series, and they do feel slightly different from the Gold pencils. But I think you can absolutely use them alongside the Gold set. The Gold set has the same issue — a lack of really light tint colors — so the Pastel Tints will help either way.

You will notice a slightly more consistent feel when blending the Pastel Tints with the Soft Touch compared to the Gold, but it’s not dramatic. Go ahead and do whatever works for you — you’re the colorist!


Price Comparison

Another important variable when choosing between the Gold and Soft Touch is price.

For this comparison, I’m using standard Amazon prices here in the US — not the amazing sale prices Castle Arts has been running lately. I also compared both sets in tin format to keep it apples to apples.

  • Gold Series (tin): $65 — approximately $0.54 per pencil
  • Soft Touch (tin): $55 — approximately $0.46 per pencil

If cost is a major factor, the Soft Touch wins.


Core Size, Composition, and Feel

Now let’s talk about the core of the pencil — how does it differ between the Gold and the Soft Touch?

Core size: The Gold set has a confirmed core size of 3.8mm, as stated in their literature. I could not find the core size listed anywhere for the Soft Touch — I searched extensively — but I can tell you from handling them that it is smaller than the Gold.

Core composition: The Gold set is advertised as oil-based, and the Soft Touch is advertised as wax-based. What does that mean in practical terms?

In my experience, the Gold set has less breakage. The colors lay down much more saturated and vibrant with less effort, and the overall feel is creamier. The Soft Touch tips break more frequently, and there are more off-center core issues in that set as well.

If performance and feel are your top priorities, I would push you toward the Gold set. They are simply more enjoyable and satisfying to color with.


Blending Test

To compare performance more concretely, I did a quick blending test. I picked a yellow, an orange, and a red from each set. From the Gold set, I chose Cadmium Orange Deep (No. 79) for the orange and Red Ochre (No. 15) for the red. I used matching numbers from the Soft Touch set.

I worked on our colored pencil paper to give both sets the best possible surface, and I used my rule of blending thirds to bring the three colors together seamlessly — which is also a great way to test layering at the same time.

After completing the test, I have to say — I felt like I was holding the Gold pencils back. They lay down so much pigment that I almost lost the yellow on the left side because I was following the same pressure I used with the Soft Touch. With the Gold pencils, you barely have to touch the paper and that orange goes on beautifully.

As far as layering goes, both sets performed really well. They’re not the best layering pencils I’ve ever worked with — that would probably be Faber-Castell Polychromos — but there was never a point where I felt like I couldn’t add another layer. Plenty of workability for a seamless blend.

For blendability: the Gold wins.


Universal Color System

One more thing worth discussing about Castle Arts is their universal color system. The idea is that the same color number corresponds to the same color across all of their product lines — watercolor pencils, both colored pencil lines, paints, all of it. I honestly don’t know how they successfully pull this off, because it has to be extremely difficult to maintain color consistency across such different product types.

I circled every pencil in the Soft Touch set that has a corresponding color number in the Gold set. So technically, No. 15 in the Gold set and No. 15 in the Soft Touch set should be the same color.

We’ve done this kind of cross-line color test before — with Faber-Castell and Caran d’Ache — and I was surprised at how consistent those brands were across their different product lines. So how does Castle Arts do?

Looking at our test of eight pencil pairs, a few things stand out right away. First — crumbs. Some pencils produce a lot of them. The Gold side has some visible crumbing on certain colors, and the Soft Touch side is pretty comparable. One pencil — No. 38 — was particularly crummy, and the black on the Soft Touch side was also very crummy. Overall, I’d call it pretty even between the two sets.

Now for the actual colors: technically, each column should look nearly identical since they share the same color number. Hold it up close and have a look. Steve just came over to weigh in.

Overall, I think it’s decent — but when we were going through and putting these in order by the color wheel, we did find some real differences that actually changed where we placed certain pencils. This brown is a good example: one reads as slightly cooler, and the other as slightly warmer. And the yellows — one has noticeably more orange in it than the other.

At first glance, you might assume they’re the same colors swatched twice. It’s only when you’re really paying close attention that the differences start to show. So if color system consistency is important to you, just know it’s decent — but not perfect.


And the Winner Is…

Okay, here’s the part where I tell you which set wins this battle, and I have to be honest — this is really difficult, because each set has genuine pros and real cons.

If you only had one budget to invest in a set right now, I still have to say: the Gold. If I sat down to color something today, I would reach for the Gold pencils because of how creamy and vibrant they are. That’s just pure coloring enjoyment.

However, if a wide color range is your priority — if you want to color from really light lights all the way to really dark darks and feel confident in your color selection — then I’d steer you toward the Soft Touch, especially with the Pastel Tints added. The cost breakdown would be $55 for the Soft Touch plus $35 for the Pastel Tints, for a total of $90 — and you’d have 168 pencils to work with. If that investment makes sense for you, it’s absolutely worth it.

Did I actually pick a winner? This one’s tough. Both are Chinese-manufactured, budget-friendly sets, and while Castle Arts makes claims about lightfastness and quality, I don’t have independent proof of those claims. All I can go on is the feel and the colors in front of me. And I think that’s exactly why I keep going back and forth without landing firmly on one — because they both have real strengths, and honestly, you’re going to be happy with either set. That’s two really solid options, which is pretty great.


Final Thoughts

So I may not have declared a clear winner — but you can win by entering the giveaway and getting them all! Then you can test them yourself and let me know which ones you prefer.

Follow the link in the video description to enter. This giveaway ends January 26th, and the winner will be announced on January 27th.

Make sure you subscribe and hit the like button — it tells us that you’re enjoying this content, and it tells YouTube too, which really helps support everything we do. The hundreds of hours we pour into swatching, sorting, and organizing these pencils for you don’t go unnoticed, and your engagement means the world.

Follow the links in the description for all your free swatch charts. I’m so glad I can do that work for you so you don’t have to!

Thanks so much to Steve for all your help — and I hope you all have a wonderful, colorful, blissful day. Bye-bye, everyone!

0 comments… add one

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.